I Mustn't Run Away: Anxiety as Ethical Condition
(Evangelion Week, Day 1)
“I mustn’t run away. I mustn’t run away. I mustn’t run away.”
This is the phrase Shinji Ikari repeats to himself like a mantra. It’s not motivational. It’s desperate—a whispered plea to override his own terror long enough to do what everyone says is necessary: pilot the Eva. Save the city. Become the self the world expects.
But the real question is: what if running away isn’t cowardice?
What if it’s epistemic honesty?
“I mustn’t run away. I mustn’t run away. I mustn’t run away.”
This is the phrase Shinji Ikari repeats to himself like a mantra. It’s not motivational. It’s desperate—a whispered plea to override his own terror long enough to do what everyone says is necessary: pilot the Eva. Save the city. Become the self the world expects.
But the real question is: what if running away isn’t cowardice?
What if it’s epistemic honesty?
Moral Paralysis Isn’t Always a Failure
We usually treat indecision as weakness. A failure to commit. A problem of will.
But Evangelion asks us to sit with the terrifying possibility that sometimes indecision is the correct response—when the weight of the task exceeds your grasp of who you are.
In Kantian terms, Shinji is a subject of duty. He’s being asked to act according to a moral law—save others, protect the world—but he doesn’t fully recognize the law as his own. The command comes from outside: from Gendo, from NERV, from the screaming of the world. But it hasn’t passed through the filter of autonomy.
So he freezes. He hesitates. He doubts.
That’s not failure. That’s an encounter with real moral weight.
We usually treat indecision as weakness. A failure to commit. A problem of will.
But Evangelion asks us to sit with the terrifying possibility that sometimes indecision is the correct response—when the weight of the task exceeds your grasp of who you are.
In Kantian terms, Shinji is a subject of duty. He’s being asked to act according to a moral law—save others, protect the world—but he doesn’t fully recognize the law as his own. The command comes from outside: from Gendo, from NERV, from the screaming of the world. But it hasn’t passed through the filter of autonomy.
So he freezes. He hesitates. He doubts.
That’s not failure. That’s an encounter with real moral weight.
Anxiety as a Kind of Integrity
Shinji doesn’t know what the right action is. But more importantly, he doesn’t know what it means to be the kind of person who acts. His anxiety isn’t just emotional—it’s ontological. He’s unsure what kind of self is even doing the choosing.
And in that sense, his fear is philosophical.
He doubts that he’s ready. That he’s enough. That he has the right to act.
That’s not just anxiety—it’s a kind of ethical integrity.
Søren Kierkegaard would probably call this the dizziness of freedom. Sartre might say it’s bad faith to act without owning the weight of your choice. And Frankfurt would note: Shinji doesn’t seem to identify with any second-order desire at all. He doesn’t want to want to pilot the Eva. He just wants out.
Shinji doesn’t know what the right action is. But more importantly, he doesn’t know what it means to be the kind of person who acts. His anxiety isn’t just emotional—it’s ontological. He’s unsure what kind of self is even doing the choosing.
And in that sense, his fear is philosophical.
He doubts that he’s ready. That he’s enough. That he has the right to act.
That’s not just anxiety—it’s a kind of ethical integrity.
Søren Kierkegaard would probably call this the dizziness of freedom. Sartre might say it’s bad faith to act without owning the weight of your choice. And Frankfurt would note: Shinji doesn’t seem to identify with any second-order desire at all. He doesn’t want to want to pilot the Eva. He just wants out.
The Hero Who Hesitates
What makes Shinji compelling isn’t that he overcomes fear.
It’s that the fear stays, and he acts anyway. Not cleanly. Not confidently. But in the suspended space between obligation and collapse.
That hesitation—that reluctance—isn’t a narrative flaw.
It’s the point.
We’re used to stories where moral agency is decisive, confident, clear. Evangelion says: sometimes, agency is barely held together.
Sometimes, doing the right thing doesn’t feel like self-assertion.
It feels like standing on a metaphysical edge and shaking.
Recommended Readings (for When You’re Emotionally in the Entry Plug)
[1] Immanuel Kant, Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals
On duty, autonomy, and why it’s not enough to just do the right thing—you have to will it for the right reason. Shinji would have a breakdown by page 12.
[2] Søren Kierkegaard, The Concept of Anxiety
Dread as the precondition for freedom. This book is the phrase “I mustn’t run away,” but in 19th-century Danish despair.
[3] Simone de Beauvoir, The Ethics of Ambiguity
What if responsibility comes not from perfect knowledge, but from action in uncertainty? A key text for anyone ethically spiraling in a robot.
[4] Harry Frankfurt, “Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person”
Do you want to want to pilot the Eva, or do you just think you’re supposed to? Frankfurt explores why our second-order desires matter.
[5] Jean-Paul Sartre, Existentialism is a Humanism
On freedom, responsibility, and why not choosing is still a choice. Pairs well with crying alone in Tokyo-3.
What makes Shinji compelling isn’t that he overcomes fear.
It’s that the fear stays, and he acts anyway. Not cleanly. Not confidently. But in the suspended space between obligation and collapse.
That hesitation—that reluctance—isn’t a narrative flaw.
It’s the point.
We’re used to stories where moral agency is decisive, confident, clear. Evangelion says: sometimes, agency is barely held together.
Sometimes, doing the right thing doesn’t feel like self-assertion.
It feels like standing on a metaphysical edge and shaking.
Recommended Readings (for When You’re Emotionally in the Entry Plug)
[1] Immanuel Kant, Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals
On duty, autonomy, and why it’s not enough to just do the right thing—you have to will it for the right reason. Shinji would have a breakdown by page 12.
[2] Søren Kierkegaard, The Concept of Anxiety
Dread as the precondition for freedom. This book is the phrase “I mustn’t run away,” but in 19th-century Danish despair.
[3] Simone de Beauvoir, The Ethics of Ambiguity
What if responsibility comes not from perfect knowledge, but from action in uncertainty? A key text for anyone ethically spiraling in a robot.
[4] Harry Frankfurt, “Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person”
Do you want to want to pilot the Eva, or do you just think you’re supposed to? Frankfurt explores why our second-order desires matter.
[5] Jean-Paul Sartre, Existentialism is a Humanism
On freedom, responsibility, and why not choosing is still a choice. Pairs well with crying alone in Tokyo-3.
Comments
Post a Comment